Cancer Society Catches Heat for Breast, Prostate Cancer Screening Criticism
October 23rd, 2009
Author: adminTop ACS Official’s Statements on Some Cancer Tests Has Docs Locked in Debate
By PEGGY PECK
MedPage Today Executive Editor
Abc News
A firestorm of controversy erupted today when a top official with the American Cancer Society let slip that the benefits of breast cancer and prostate cancer screening may have been oversold.
The epicenter of the controversy is statement by Dr. Otis Brawley, chief medical officer of the ACS. Brawley made the statement in an interview with the New York Times about a Journal of the American Medical Association analysis of breast and prostate cancer screening, which raised questions about claims that screening saves lives.
Brawley said the questions raised in the journal article were legitimate, and he said the ACS was in the process of reworking its message on breast and prostate cancer screening. According to the Times report, he said the benefits of screening had been “exaggerated.”
When ABC News contacted the ACS for an interview with Brawley, it was told that he was attending a family funeral and was not available for comment.
The ACS did, however, release a prepared statement under Brawley’s name: “While the advantages of screening for some cancers have been overstated, there are advantages, especially in the case of breast, colon and cervical cancers. Mammography is effective – mammograms work and women should continue get them… The American Cancer Society stands by its recommendation that women age 40 and over should receive annual mammography, and women at high risk should talk with their doctors about when screening should begin based on their family history.”Read more…
Category: 
| 
Leave a Reply
Cancer Society Catches Heat for Breast, Prostate Cancer Screening Criticism
October 23rd, 2009 Author: adminTop ACS Official’s Statements on Some Cancer Tests Has Docs Locked in Debate
By PEGGY PECK
MedPage Today Executive Editor
Abc News
A firestorm of controversy erupted today when a top official with the American Cancer Society let slip that the benefits of breast cancer and prostate cancer screening may have been oversold.
The epicenter of the controversy is statement by Dr. Otis Brawley, chief medical officer of the ACS. Brawley made the statement in an interview with the New York Times about a Journal of the American Medical Association analysis of breast and prostate cancer screening, which raised questions about claims that screening saves lives.
Brawley said the questions raised in the journal article were legitimate, and he said the ACS was in the process of reworking its message on breast and prostate cancer screening. According to the Times report, he said the benefits of screening had been “exaggerated.”
When ABC News contacted the ACS for an interview with Brawley, it was told that he was attending a family funeral and was not available for comment.
The ACS did, however, release a prepared statement under Brawley’s name: “While the advantages of screening for some cancers have been overstated, there are advantages, especially in the case of breast, colon and cervical cancers. Mammography is effective – mammograms work and women should continue get them… The American Cancer Society stands by its recommendation that women age 40 and over should receive annual mammography, and women at high risk should talk with their doctors about when screening should begin based on their family history.”Read more…
